Calm shows

Overstimulating shows: the signs, and a calmer swap for each

The episode ends, you take the tablet, and your 3-year-old falls apart in a way that has little to do with the tablet. Or the show is still running and your child is staring at it without blinking, then cannot settle to anything for half an hour. You start to wonder whether it is screens in general, or whether some shows are simply too much for toddlers and preschoolers.

Often it is the show. High-stimulation shows for toddlers have a few things in common: the picture changes every one or two seconds, music never stops, the colours are as bright as the screen allows and everyone talks fast. The signs show up in the minutes after watching, and for almost every busy show there is a calmer one with the same appeal. Both are below.

If you want your child's tablet to play only the calmer ones, Pepelly shows a child only the channels you chose, with no autoplay and no recommendations in between. More on that at the end.

This guide is for older toddlers and preschoolers from about 3. For children under 18 to 24 months, the American Academy of Pediatrics advises avoiding screen media apart from video chatting, so there is no list for that age here.[3]“American Academy of Pediatrics: Media and Young Minds (2016)”.

What high stimulation means in shows for toddlers

A high-stimulation show sends a child a lot of new input every second. A low-stimulation show sends little, and leaves gaps. That is the whole of the low stimulation meaning: it describes how a show is made, not what it teaches or whether it is good.

Neither phrase is an official rating. Parents and educators use them for four things you can see and hear:

  • Cut rate. How often the picture changes. Busy shows cut every one or two seconds. Calm shows hold a shot long enough to look around in it.
  • Music. Whether music and sound effects run under every scene, or come and go and leave silence.
  • Colour. Saturated, high-contrast colour on every surface, or softer and natural tones.
  • Narration. How fast the characters talk, how loud they are, and whether there are pauses a child can think in.

We use the same four criteria in our guide to low-stimulation shows for toddlers and preschoolers, with three ratings: calm, medium and lively. "Overstimulating" is the word parents use for the lively end when it is too much for their child. That last part matters. A show is lively by how it is made. Whether it is overstimulating depends on the child, the time of day and how long it runs.

Signs that a show was too much

There is no checklist a doctor would sign. These are things parents commonly notice in the minutes after a busy show, and they are worth comparing with how the same child behaves after a slow one.

Stopping is far harder than usual. Every child protests when a screen goes off. After a fast show the protest is bigger and longer, and it starts the moment the video ends.

Waiting and small rules fall apart. Shoes on, wash hands, wait for your turn. Things your child managed this morning are suddenly out of reach. This is the sign closest to what the research below measured.

Play is restless. Your child goes from toy to toy without settling, or runs in circles, or asks for the show again and again and wants nothing else.

The stare. During the show your child does not answer when you speak, does not laugh, does not point at anything. A child who is following a story reacts to it. A child who is only being held by the pace often does not.

Winding down takes longer. After a busy show in the evening, the bath, the book and the bed all go slower.

One sign on one day means little. Hunger, a missed nap and a long day at nursery look the same. What counts is the pattern: if the same thing follows the same show most days, and does not follow a slower one, the show is a fair suspect.

What the research says about pace

The best-known study is small and careful. In 2011, Angeline Lillard and Jennifer Peterson had sixty 4-year-olds spend nine minutes watching a fast-paced cartoon, watching a slower educational cartoon, or drawing. Straight afterwards, the children who had watched the fast cartoon did worse on tasks that measure executive function: waiting for a reward, remembering a rule, holding back an impulse.[1]“Lillard & Peterson (2011): The immediate impact of different types of television on young children's executive function. Pediatrics 128(4)”.

Two points keep that in proportion. The study measured children right after watching. It did not show lasting change, and the authors said so.[1]“Lillard & Peterson (2011): The immediate impact of different types of television on young children's executive function. Pediatrics 128(4)”. And a 2015 follow-up by Lillard and colleagues found that fantastical content, meaning characters who do impossible things and scenes that keep transforming, mattered as much as pace on its own, or more.[2]“Lillard et al. (2015): Further examination of the immediate impact of television on children's executive function. Developmental Psychology 51(6)”. A slow show full of magic is not automatically the gentle choice.

The American Academy of Pediatrics draws a practical line from this. For children aged 2 to 5 it advises about one hour a day of high-quality programming, watched together where possible. It names fast-paced programmes, apps with lots of distracting content and violent content as the ones to avoid, and it advises no screens in the hour before bed.[3]“American Academy of Pediatrics: Media and Young Minds (2016)”.

None of this says that a lively show damages a child. It says that after one, a small child may find it harder to wait and to stop, which is exactly the moment most families fight about.

Overstimulating shows, and a calmer swap for each

These are the shows parents ask about most, with our own pace rating and a swap that keeps what the child likes about the original. The ratings are an editorial judgement from watching single episodes, not a measurement.

Cocomelon. Nursery rhymes in glossy 3D. The camera cuts every couple of seconds, a song runs the whole time and the colours are as bright as they come. It is made for the youngest viewers, the group the research is most careful about. The calmer swap is Little Fox for stories and songs sung slowly and clearly, or Puffin Rock when the point is to wind down. Fits 3 to 4, in short single videos.

Blippi. A man in orange and blue visits fire stations, farms and indoor playgrounds. The topics are good. The delivery is loud and fast, with a sound effect on every movement and music underneath. The calmer swap is Tractor Ted, which shows real farm machines filmed steadily and narrated simply, or Discover, Grow, Bloom with Garden Marcus, where a gardener plants seeds at a toddler's pace. Fits 3 to 5.

PAW Patrol. Every episode is an emergency, a rollout, vehicles and a rescue, and the cuts and the music match that. It is the show parents most often name when a child is wired at bedtime. The calmer swap is Octonauts, which keeps the rescues and the vehicles and adds real sea creatures and quieter stretches. For a vehicle friend with no sirens at all, Trash Truck on Netflix is about as slow as animation gets. Fits 4 to 7.

Mickey Mouse Clubhouse. Mickey asks the child a question and waits for the answer, which is good. Around that, the 3D world is shiny, music sits under almost every line and the songs are loud. The calmer swap is Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood: the same direct talk to the child, one problem and one strategy per episode, at half the volume. Fits 3 to 5.

Toy and surprise-opening videos. These are a format more than a show. Quick cuts, squealing voices, bright packaging and a new object every few seconds, with no story to follow. If your child likes watching hands do things, a read-aloud works better. StorylineOnline and Brightly Storytime hold a picture-book page on screen while someone reads it. Fits 3 to 6.

Hours-long compilations. A calm seven-minute episode stops being calm when it is the fourth in a two-hour block. Many official channels post these next to their single episodes. The swap is the same show as one episode. Check the length before you press play. On a preschool channel, anything over about twenty minutes is usually a compilation.

Our pace ratings for 12 popular kids' shows put Bluey, Peppa Pig, Sesame Street, Ms Rachel and the shows above in one table, criterion by criterion. If the swap should also teach letters or numbers, our list of educational shows for toddlers and preschoolers sorts calm channels by subject.

How to check a show yourself in two minutes

You do not need a rating from anyone. Sit next to your child and do this once per show.

  1. Count the cuts for thirty seconds. If you lose count, the show is lively. If you get to five or six, it is calm.
  2. Listen for silence. Does the music ever stop?
  3. Look at the colours. Is every surface bright, or are there soft tones too?
  4. Listen to the voices. Could your child answer a question before the next line comes?
  5. Watch your child, not the screen. A child who points, laughs and talks back is following the story.

Then watch what happens when it ends. That is the real test, and it is specific to your child.

What to do after a lively show

You do not have to ban the favourite. Three small changes do most of the work.

Move it earlier. A lively show at four in the afternoon, with the garden afterwards, is a different thing from the same show at seven. Keep the last hour before bed for calm shows or no screen at all, as the AAP advises.[3]“American Academy of Pediatrics: Media and Young Minds (2016)”.

Agree on the end before the start. "One episode, then we build the train track" works better than a negotiation when the credits roll. Count in episodes, not minutes, so the end is something your child can see coming.

Follow it with something for the body. Jumping, carrying, water, outside. Ten minutes of that often does what ten minutes of asking a child to calm down does not.

Keeping the calm swap calm on YouTube

The swap only works if the calm show is what actually plays. On YouTube, autoplay can start a new video when yours ends, and the suggestions around the video lead back to the busy shows within a few taps. You can turn off autoplay on YouTube for kids on every device, and it is worth doing. The suggestions stay. YouTube Kids has a mode called Approve content yourself, where you pick the channels and search is off. It is free, though it does not hide compilations from the channels you approved.

Pepelly is a video player for children from 6 to 12 that plays only the channels you approved. There are no Shorts, no autoplay, no recommendations and no comments. Compilations and very long videos are hidden by default, and when an episode ends, Pepelly shows its own screen with "watch again" or "back to my videos". The free plan covers one child, ten channels and a daily limit, which is enough for the calm swaps above.

Two honest notes. Videos play in the official YouTube player, and Pepelly does not remove YouTube ads. Pepelly is not affiliated with YouTube or Google. See how Pepelly works.

Questions

What are high-stimulation shows for toddlers?

High-stimulation shows are programmes with very fast cuts, music and sound effects under almost every scene, saturated colours and fast, loud voices. There is no official label. It is a description of pace and style that parents can see and hear for themselves.

What does low stimulation mean?

Low stimulation means a show asks little of a child's attention from moment to moment. Scenes last long enough to understand, the soundtrack leaves room for quiet, the colours are soft and the characters speak slowly with pauses. It describes how a show is made, not what it teaches.

Is Cocomelon overstimulating?

We rate Cocomelon as lively, the busiest of our three ratings. The picture cuts every couple of seconds, a song runs the whole time and the colours are very bright. Whether that is too much depends on the child and the time of day. Short single videos in the afternoon are a different thing from a long compilation before bed.

Do overstimulating shows harm toddlers?

The research does not show lasting harm. Lillard and Peterson (2011) found that 4-year-olds did worse on self-control tasks straight after nine minutes of a fast-paced cartoon, and the authors said the study measured only that short-term effect. The American Academy of Pediatrics advises avoiding fast-paced programmes for children aged 2 to 5.

How can I tell if a show is too stimulating for my child?

Watch two minutes with your child and count how often the picture changes, listen for silence, and look at the colours. Then watch your child after the show ends. If stopping is much harder than after a slower show, or play afterwards is restless, try a calmer show at that time of day.

Sources

Pepelly uses primary sources: Google and Apple help pages, regulators, paediatric bodies and peer-reviewed studies. Read our editorial standards.

  1. Lillard & Peterson (2011): The immediate impact of different types of television on young children's executive function. Pediatrics 128(4) ↩
  2. Lillard et al. (2015): Further examination of the immediate impact of television on children's executive function. Developmental Psychology 51(6) ↩
  3. American Academy of Pediatrics: Media and Young Minds (2016) ↩

Only the channels you choose. Nothing else.

Create your free account in the browser and pick your child's channels tonight. Pairing your child's tablet or phone follows with the app.

Start free on the web

Coming soon to iPhone, iPad and Android.

Free for one child with up to ten channels. Family forever: 29.99 EUR once. All about pricing