YouTube Kids vs Pepelly: an honest comparison from the maker
You have YouTube Kids on your child's tablet, it mostly works, and you have heard of Pepelly. Now you want to know whether switching is worth the trouble. We make Pepelly, so read this as the maker's comparison, written as fairly as we can manage.
Here is the verdict on YouTube Kids vs Pepelly in two sentences. YouTube Kids is free, made by Google and has a far larger library, chosen for your child by filters and recommendations. Pepelly is an allowlist player: you pick every channel, and your child sees those channels with no Shorts, no autoplay, no recommendations and no search beyond them.
If that second sentence is what you are after, the free plan covers one child, ten channels and a daily limit. The rest of this page explains the differences row by row, including where each app falls short.
The main difference: who chooses the videos
In YouTube Kids, a system chooses. The app draws from the videos on YouTube and lets through the ones its filters rate as suitable for an age group: Preschool, Younger or Older. Inside that pool, the home screen and the rows under each video come from recommendations, so the next video is the one the system expects your child to tap.[1]“YouTube Kids Help: Parental controls for YouTube Kids profiles”. Our guide on whether YouTube Kids is safe explains what that filter catches and what gets through.
YouTube Kids has one mode that changes this. With Approve content yourself switched on, your child sees only the channels, videos and collections you approved, and search is off.[1]“YouTube Kids Help: Parental controls for YouTube Kids profiles”. It is the closest YouTube Kids comes to Pepelly, and it is free.
In Pepelly, you choose, and nothing else does. There is no pool behind your list. It works as an allowlist: you add channels by search, by pasting a link, from a starter pack for your child's age, or from your own YouTube subscriptions. Your child sees the newest video from every one of those channels first, what they have already watched last, and nothing in between.
YouTube Kids vs Pepelly, side by side
Each row describes the app as its maker documents it. For YouTube Kids that is Google's help pages. For Pepelly that is our own site, and the pricing page is the source for prices.
| YouTube Kids | Pepelly | |
|---|---|---|
| Who chooses the content | Filters and recommendations within an age group; you choose in Approve content yourself | You choose every channel |
| Library | A large filtered catalogue drawn from YouTube | Only the channels you add |
| Shorts | No Shorts feed | None |
| Autoplay | A parent can switch it off for the profile | None; a video ends on "watch again" or "back to my videos" |
| Recommendations | Yes, unless you approve content yourself | None |
| Search for the child | A switch in the profile; off in Approve content yourself | Only within your approved channels |
| Ads | Paid ads before some videos, reviewed and not personalised | YouTube's ads, as the channel runs them; Pepelly does not remove YouTube ads |
| Price | Free; YouTube Premium removes the paid ads | Free for one child and ten channels; Family 29.99 EUR once, 19.99 EUR a year or 3.99 EUR a month |
| Platforms | iPhone, iPad, Android, smart TVs, browser | Kid mode on iPhone, iPad and Android phones and tablets; parent mode on the phone or in the web dashboard |
| Child data | A profile under your Google Account, watch history recorded | No account for the child: name, avatar, age band, approved channels, watch time |
| Ages | Three age groups up to 12 | 6 to 12, with an age band per child |
Two rows need a word more. On ads, both apps play YouTube's ads. Google says the paid ads in YouTube Kids go through a separate review, are not personalised and do not open a website when tapped.[2]“YouTube Kids Help: Ads in YouTube Kids”. Videos in Pepelly play in the official YouTube player, and Pepelly does not remove YouTube ads. Our guide on what ads YouTube Kids shows and what parents can change covers the product videos that no ad setting touches.
On price, Pepelly Family adds more children, more channels, bedtime, rules for single videos, a running video that may finish when time is up, and a weekly report for each child. The yearly plan starts with 7 days free. The app shows prices in your store's currency, and you buy in the app only, through the App Store or Google Play.[4]“Pepelly: Pricing”.
Where Pepelly falls short
We would rather you hear this from us than find it out in week two.
The library is as big as your list. YouTube Kids opens on a full home screen on the first day. Pepelly shows nothing until you add channels or start from a pack. If your child loves discovering new things, that can feel thin.
A parent has to do the choosing. Pepelly does not decide what is good for your child. That is the point, and it is also work. You need to know, or find out, which channels you trust, and our list of the best YouTube channels for kids is one place to start.
An approved channel is approved whole. If a calm channel starts posting sponsored toy videos, they appear. Compilations and very long videos stay hidden by default, and every hidden video sits in a list under your child's profile with the reason. A 12-minute unboxing is neither, so it gets through.
It is still YouTube's player. Ads that a channel runs play in Pepelly too, and Google can receive data such as the device's IP address when a video plays.
There is no TV app. Kid mode runs on phones and tablets. YouTube Kids runs on smart TVs and in a browser.
It is new. YouTube Kids has Google behind it and years of use. Pepelly is made by one father through a small company in Tallinn. The person who answers the support email is the person who wrote the app, which cuts both ways.
Where YouTube Kids falls short
These points come from Google's own help pages, not from our view of the app.
The default is an algorithm. Unless you switch on Approve content yourself, recommendation systems choose the home screen and the next video from the pool for your child's age group. Google says its filters are not perfect and asks parents to block and report videos that slip through.[1]“YouTube Kids Help: Parental controls for YouTube Kids profiles”.
Approve content yourself is the closest mode, and it has limits. You approve channels one at a time inside the child's app.[1]“YouTube Kids Help: Parental controls for YouTube Kids profiles”. A channel you want may not be in YouTube Kids at all. And nothing in the mode filters by length, so an approved channel's three-hour compilations come along with its episodes.
Autoplay is your job to switch off. A parent can turn it off for the profile, from Family Center in the parent's own YouTube app.[3]“YouTube Help: Understand your choices as a family”. While it is on, the next video starts by itself.
Search is a wide door. With search on, your child can type or say a word and get results from the whole catalogue for their age group. You can turn it off in the profile settings.[1]“YouTube Kids Help: Parental controls for YouTube Kids profiles”.
If you stay with YouTube Kids, the checklist in our YouTube Kids safety guide closes most of these gaps. Our guide to YouTube parental controls covers the supervised account for older children.
Which one fits your family
Choose YouTube Kids if your child is a preschooler whose favourite shows are all in the app, if you watch on the TV, or if you want a free app that works on the first day. Switch on Approve content yourself, turn off autoplay and search, and set the timer.
Choose Pepelly if you have already decided which channels are fine and want that decision to be the end of the job. It fits a six-year-old whose channels are missing from YouTube Kids, and a ten-year-old who is done with cartoon icons but not ready for the open app. When a video ends, Pepelly's own screen appears, so there is no next row to tap. Your child can ask for a channel from inside the app, and the request lands as a notification on your phone.
Use both if that suits you. Some families keep YouTube Kids on the TV and use Pepelly on the tablet. Either way, the app holds the rules only inside itself. Lock the YouTube app and the browser with Screen Time on iPhone and iPad or Family Link on Android. Pepelly walks you through it.
If you are still weighing other options, such as catalogue apps or a supervised account, our comparison of YouTube Kids alternatives puts them all in one table. To try Pepelly with one child and ten channels, see how Pepelly works.
Pepelly is not affiliated with YouTube or Google. YouTube is a trademark of Google LLC.
Questions
Is Pepelly YouTube Kids?
No. Pepelly is a separate app by an independent maker and is not affiliated with YouTube or Google. It plays YouTube videos in the official YouTube player, but only from the channels a parent approved. There is no catalogue, no search of YouTube for the child and no recommendations.
Can I use YouTube Kids and Pepelly at the same time?
Yes. Some families keep YouTube Kids on the living-room TV and use Pepelly on the child's tablet. If you want your child to watch only in Pepelly on a device, lock the YouTube Kids app, the YouTube app and the browser there with Screen Time on iPhone and iPad or Family Link on Android.
Does Pepelly need a Google account?
Not for your child. You sign in as the parent with Google or Apple, and your child gets a profile with a name, an avatar and an age band, with no email address or password. YouTube Kids, by contrast, keeps your child's profile under your Google Account.
Is Pepelly better than YouTube Kids?
It depends on what you want the app to do. YouTube Kids is free, has a far larger library and runs on TVs. Pepelly suits a parent who wants to choose every channel and wants no Shorts, no autoplay, no recommendations and no search beyond those channels in the child's app.
Sources
Pepelly uses primary sources: Google and Apple help pages, regulators, paediatric bodies and peer-reviewed studies. Read our editorial standards.
Only the channels you choose. Nothing else.
Create your free account in the browser and pick your child's channels tonight. Pairing your child's tablet or phone follows with the app.
Coming soon to iPhone, iPad and Android.
Free for one child with up to ten channels. Family forever: 29.99 EUR once. All about pricing
Related guides
YouTube Kids alternatives, compared honestly
YouTube Kids alternatives compared: Approve content yourself, supervised accounts, curated apps and whitelist players, by Shorts, autoplay, ads, price and data.
Screen time apps for kids: built-in tools vs paid apps
Looking for the best screen time app for kids? Start with free Screen Time and Family Link, see what paid apps add, and fix limits that are not working.
Screen time before bed: how long before sleep, and the last video
Screen time before bed: when to switch off, what the AAP and WHO advise on sleep, calm bedtime shows from 3, and how to end the last video without a fight.